Re: panel update
Posted: Fri Dec 13, 2013 6:46 pm
At the Spares Group meeting at Stoneleigh this point was discussed at length and the unanimous decision was that half wings were the way to go.
The points made were that:
1. If the arch has gone then the front and rear lower corners will almost certainly be gone and it is silly not to do the job in one hit.
2. If only replacing the arch because the front/rear corners seem OK ...... it is likely that in the future these corners will have to be replaced anyway so have the parts available.
3. If only replacing the arch ..... how far round people want will vary.
4. It is better to have one piece welded in to make a repair rather than three pieces.
5. A weld along a straight line (as in the top of the half wing) is much easier/better than a weld around the corner as in an arch ...... it is shorter as well!
6. It is wholly unrealistic and not cost effective to make lots of sections. Puts up the cost and if a half wing is supplied people can cut off what they want
Lloyd is doing a great job and putting in lots of time and effort - don't make it harder for him than it needs to be.
MUT
The points made were that:
1. If the arch has gone then the front and rear lower corners will almost certainly be gone and it is silly not to do the job in one hit.
2. If only replacing the arch because the front/rear corners seem OK ...... it is likely that in the future these corners will have to be replaced anyway so have the parts available.
3. If only replacing the arch ..... how far round people want will vary.
4. It is better to have one piece welded in to make a repair rather than three pieces.
5. A weld along a straight line (as in the top of the half wing) is much easier/better than a weld around the corner as in an arch ...... it is shorter as well!
6. It is wholly unrealistic and not cost effective to make lots of sections. Puts up the cost and if a half wing is supplied people can cut off what they want
Lloyd is doing a great job and putting in lots of time and effort - don't make it harder for him than it needs to be.
MUT