Registration problems
- Alan Chatterton
- Senior Member
- Posts:2945
- Joined:Fri Feb 06, 2004 11:18 pm
- Location:Redditch, Worcestershire
We have just been hit by another load of spam registrations. I had 127 to deal with this morning, and all of them have been deleted and banned by IP.
I suspect they are spammers as I can't imagine people from kazakhstan being interested in our cars!!
However, if a "real one" got lost in this, please contact me directly and I will sort it out.
I suspect they are spammers as I can't imagine people from kazakhstan being interested in our cars!!
However, if a "real one" got lost in this, please contact me directly and I will sort it out.
Alan Chatterton
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
- Alan Chatterton
- Senior Member
- Posts:2945
- Joined:Fri Feb 06, 2004 11:18 pm
- Location:Redditch, Worcestershire
Re: Registration problems
It would seem that PHPBB (our forum providers) have had their servers "compromised" in some way, which is allowing these spoof registrations to get through the usual anti spam checks.
We hope they can resolve it quickly, so that we can re open to new registrations.
Bear with us please.
Alan
We hope they can resolve it quickly, so that we can re open to new registrations.
Bear with us please.
Alan
Alan Chatterton
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
- David Withers
- Senior Member
- Posts:1230
- Joined:Tue Mar 22, 2005 11:28 am
- Location:North Cambridgeshire, UK
- Contact:
Re: Registration problems
The phpBB forum that I administer hasn't suffered from spam registrations since I dispensed with Captcha and implemented instead a Question and Answer. I made sure to ask a question to which there could be only one answer, and one that any person not involved in the subject matter of the forum would be unlikely to know without searching.
I can't recall the form of the Register's anti-spam check as it's a long while since I registered, but perhaps it wasn't sufficiently strong?
While I'm here, I'll mention that when I want to take a look at the forum using my iPad instead of the desktop computer, I'm 'spammed' with the invitation to activate Tapatalk. What an annoying app!
I can't recall the form of the Register's anti-spam check as it's a long while since I registered, but perhaps it wasn't sufficiently strong?
While I'm here, I'll mention that when I want to take a look at the forum using my iPad instead of the desktop computer, I'm 'spammed' with the invitation to activate Tapatalk. What an annoying app!
- Alan Chatterton
- Senior Member
- Posts:2945
- Joined:Fri Feb 06, 2004 11:18 pm
- Location:Redditch, Worcestershire
Re: Registration problems
We do use captcha, and it is up to date, perhaps the simple q&a would work?
I use touchbb lite on my iPhone and iPad for this forum, and it's pretty good. I never get 'asked' for tapatalk unless I log in on a browser on the iPhone.
I use touchbb lite on my iPhone and iPad for this forum, and it's pretty good. I never get 'asked' for tapatalk unless I log in on a browser on the iPhone.
Alan Chatterton
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
- TedTaylor
- Senior Member
- Posts:1670
- Joined:Sat Dec 06, 2008 11:27 pm
- Location:Forest of Dean (Gloucestershire)
Re: Registration problems
I just use a fat finger .......Alan Chatterton wrote:I use touchbb lite on my iPhone and iPad for this forum, and it's pretty good. I never get 'asked' for tapatalk unless I log in on a browser on the iPhone.
MUT
Member 4473 1990
1964 2000 period rally look alike AFH 849B
Morris 1800 London-Sydney/Monte/WCR NAM 616G
Mk1 PI Estate SCG 115G
2500 Estate WDE 76K RBRR 2014
1964 2000 period rally look alike AFH 849B
Morris 1800 London-Sydney/Monte/WCR NAM 616G
Mk1 PI Estate SCG 115G
2500 Estate WDE 76K RBRR 2014
- David Withers
- Senior Member
- Posts:1230
- Joined:Tue Mar 22, 2005 11:28 am
- Location:North Cambridgeshire, UK
- Contact:
Re: Registration problems
I was using Captcha as the check when spam registrations started coming in (not many, but enough to give me a warning). I found reports, on phpBB's help forum and elsewhere, that spammers had developed programs to automatically overcome Captcha. Also, some people (myself included) can find it difficult to read a Captcha.Alan Chatterton wrote:We do use captcha, and it is up to date, perhaps the simple q&a would work?
I use touchbb lite on my iPhone and iPad for this forum, and it's pretty good. I never get 'asked' for tapatalk unless I log in on a browser on the iPhone.
Q&A was said to be much stronger, and I'm sure it is, especially if a bit harder than, e.g., "2+3 =?" as such sums are fairly popular for Q&A and may not be sufficiently robust against spammers software. I've not been troubled by spam registrations since adopting Q&A, and that was two or three years ago. The question I ask is "In which city is the NRM based?", which the majority of, if not all, potential forum members will know the answer to. Spammers, especially those based overseas, would probably need to do an internet search for the answer, and hopefully that would be too much trouble for them. I deliberately use the initials NRM rather than the full name so as to make it that bit harder for spammers.
I've been logging into the Register forum via Bing on my tablet, so that is why I keep receiving the Tapatalk invitation. Thanks for pointing that out, Alan, though it shouldn't happen as it's still an unsolicited intrusion (i.e. spam!). I'll restrict to logging in on the desktop computer in future; it's more user friendly anyway in situations where the portability of a tablet is not needed.
Last edited by David Withers on Tue Dec 16, 2014 11:31 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Alan Chatterton
- Senior Member
- Posts:2945
- Joined:Fri Feb 06, 2004 11:18 pm
- Location:Redditch, Worcestershire
Re: Registration problems
I've looked at the settings and there doesn't appear to be an option to turn the tapatalk request off.
I'll look over the weekend and change the security to q&a hopefully that will sort it.
I'll look over the weekend and change the security to q&a hopefully that will sort it.
Alan Chatterton
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
- David Withers
- Senior Member
- Posts:1230
- Joined:Tue Mar 22, 2005 11:28 am
- Location:North Cambridgeshire, UK
- Contact:
Re: Registration problems
Alan, thanks for looking into the Tapatalk thing.
Note that I've edited (almost re-written!) my post since you put your last one up. I've added a bit more detail to my argument for Q&A and have included, as an example, the Question that appears on the forum I administer. I feel confident that your planned change to Q&A on the Register forum will pay dividends.
Note that I've edited (almost re-written!) my post since you put your last one up. I've added a bit more detail to my argument for Q&A and have included, as an example, the Question that appears on the forum I administer. I feel confident that your planned change to Q&A on the Register forum will pay dividends.
- Alan Chatterton
- Senior Member
- Posts:2945
- Joined:Fri Feb 06, 2004 11:18 pm
- Location:Redditch, Worcestershire
Re: Registration problems
Following on from David's very helpful advice, registrations are now open again!!!
Fingers crossed we get no unfriendly visitors back this time!
Fingers crossed we get no unfriendly visitors back this time!
Alan Chatterton
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
- Alan Chatterton
- Senior Member
- Posts:2945
- Joined:Fri Feb 06, 2004 11:18 pm
- Location:Redditch, Worcestershire
Re: Registration problems
3 days on, still no problems!!
Sorted I think!
Sorted I think!
Alan Chatterton
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
Location; Redditch
DEL 33 1972 Lines Stag Estate Tartan Red
Blog http://vml3m.blogspot.com/
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests